Skip to main content

Are Be(OH)2 and CF3Cl polar or non-polar? What is the reason?

3 Answers

K
Kelsie Sawayn

Feb 20, 2025

I’d call both nonpolar (1) look at electronegativities to determine if the bonds are polar(2) look for symmetry. a molecule with polar bonds is NON polar if it is symmetric!here’s a table of ENhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronegativitywhen it comes groups.. like -OH.. things get a bit more complicated. Oone of the simpliest approximations ishttp://pages.unibas.ch/mdpi/ecsoc/e0002/calelecg.h…in -O-H.. the are 2 O bonds (2×3.44) & 1 H bond (1×2.20) for a total EN of (2*3.44+1×2.20)/3 = 3.03The rules of thumb for determining the type of bond go..if ΔEN < 0.5, the bond is nonpolar covalentif 0.5 < ΔEN < 1.5, the bond is polar covalent if 1.5 < ΔEN < 2.0 AND no metal is present, the bond is polar covalentif 1.5 < ΔEN < 2.0 AND a metal is present, the bond is ionicif 2.0 < ΔEN, the bond is ionicand again.. those are rules of thumbin Be(OH)2.. .the Be-OH bond had ΔEN = 3.03 – 1.57 = 1.46… so this should be a polar covalent bondin CF3Cl, ΔEN between C and F = 3.98 – 2.55 = 1.43.. ΔEN between C and Cl is 3.16 – 2.55 = 0.61.. and all the bonds are polar covalentas to symmetry…it turns out Be(OH)2 is in fact a linear molecule.. H-O-Be-O-H.. so it has "electronic symmetry" and the different areas of high electron density cancel out.CF3Cl is also a symmetric molecule. it’s shape is tetrahedron. and therefore is non polar.. now both molecules will actually have areas of partial charges.. F has a higher EN than Cl so it will withdraw slightly more electron density from the carbon than the Cl will. But what we’re doing here is looking at a broad range of values and drawing lines in the sand and saying if you’re on this side your polar and on that side your not. Get it? I think CF3Cl is on the non polar side of that line. in any case..polar molecules must have polar bondspolar molecules cannot have electronic symmetry.how about that.. 3 of the usual answerers here on YA. 3 different answers.... Show More
K
Kelsie Sawayn

Feb 20, 2025

CF3Cl is polar because this forms a tetrahedral molecule, but because you have different substituents, there is a net dipole moment in the molecule.I would consider Be(OH)2 to be an ionic compound. I don’t think ionic compounds are generally considered to be either polar or non-polar.... Show More
K
Kelsie Sawayn

Feb 20, 2025

Be(OH)2 is linear thus canceling any effect of polar bondsCF3Cl is tetrahedral with one corner occupied by F which is more electronegative than the Cl’sso it is somewhat polar... Show More

Want to answer this question?

Join our community to share your knowledge!

Categories

Tags

Related Questions

9
are big black moths good or bad luck?

right now, there is a big dark brown almost black moth on one of the windows of my kitchen. is it good or bad luck, and...

11
Are Blue Eyes Considered An Exotic Physical Feature In Puerto Rico ?

I have a Puerto Rican friend who has blue eyes and he tells me that back in Puerto Rico he is considered exotic looking...

10
are bone thugs n harmony crips?

yeah was wondering if bone thugs n harmony were crips or something.

7
Are cookies considered Bread?

i am giving up bread for Lent, & I was wondering if Girl Scout Cookies are considered Bread. Thin Mints & Dosidos.

10
Are cosmetic dental grants a scam? There is a site called….?

www.cosmeticdentistrygrants.org. Now I have like 5 teeth missing and was looking for implants. THey said that I can go t...