Rocky Beier
Nov 24, 2024
Are Be(OH)2 and CF3Cl polar or non-polar? What is the reason?
Are beryllium hydroxide (Be(OH)2) and trifluoromethane (CF3Cl) polar or non-polar? What are the reasons for their classifications?
3 Answers
I’d call both nonpolar
(1) look at electronegativities to determine if the bonds are polar
(2) look for symmetry. a molecule with polar bonds is NON polar if it is symmetric!
here’s a table of EN
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronegativity
when it comes groups.. like -OH.. things get a bit more complicated. Oone of the simpliest approximations is
http://pages.unibas.ch/mdpi/ecsoc/e0002/calelecg.h…
in -O-H.. the are 2 O bonds (2×3.44) & 1 H bond (1×2.20) for a total EN of (2*3.44+1×2.20)/3 = 3.03
The rules of thumb for determining the type of bond go..
if ΔEN < 0.5, the bond is nonpolar covalent
if 0.5 < ΔEN < 1.5, the bond is polar covalent
if 1.5 < ΔEN < 2.0 AND no metal is present, the bond is polar covalent
if 1.5 < ΔEN < 2.0 AND a metal is present, the bond is ionic
if 2.0 < ΔEN, the bond is ionic
and again.. those are rules of thumb
in Be(OH)2.. .the Be-OH bond had ΔEN = 3.03 – 1.57 = 1.46… so this should be a polar covalent bond
in CF3Cl, ΔEN between C and F = 3.98 – 2.55 = 1.43.. ΔEN between C and Cl is 3.16 – 2.55 = 0.61.. and all the bonds are polar covalent
as to symmetry…
it turns out Be(OH)2 is in fact a linear molecule.. H-O-Be-O-H.. so it has "electronic symmetry" and the different areas of high electron density cancel out.
CF3Cl is also a symmetric molecule. it’s shape is tetrahedron. and therefore is non polar..
now both molecules will actually have areas of partial charges.. F has a higher EN than Cl so it will withdraw slightly more electron density from the carbon than the Cl will. But what we’re doing here is looking at a broad range of values and drawing lines in the sand and saying if you’re on this side your polar and on that side your not. Get it? I think CF3Cl is on the non polar side of that line.
in any case..
polar molecules must have polar bonds
polar molecules cannot have electronic symmetry.
how about that.. 3 of the usual answerers here on YA. 3 different answers.
CF3Cl is polar because this forms a tetrahedral molecule, but because you have different substituents, there is a net dipole moment in the molecule.
I would consider Be(OH)2 to be an ionic compound. I don’t think ionic compounds are generally considered to be either polar or non-polar.
Related Questions
How many oxygen atoms are in 2.00 grams of quartz? Could someone please provide a detailed explanation of the calculatio...
How many moles of CO2 are produced when 5.45 moles of ethane (C2H6) are burned in an excess of oxygen?
Suppose there are two known compounds containing the elements x and y, and you have a 1.00 g sample of each compound. Wh...
What is the hybridization of the phosphorus atom in PCl3? Additionally, could you please provide an explanation of the s...
¿Cuál es la tendencia de los metales al formar enlaces? ¿Qué rango de edad sería el adecuado para explicar esta respuest...
How many moles of copper (Cu) are present in 1.48 × 10²⁵ atoms of copper?
Together, leukocytes and platelets comprise approximately a certain percentage of total blood volume. In biological ter...
What is the hybridization of the central atom in the molecules CH2F2 (difluoromethane) and COF2 (carbonyl fluoride)? Add...
What are the steps to create an energy level diagram for aluminum? Could you provide detailed guidance on how to accurat...
How many moles of CuO can be produced from 0.450 moles of Cu2O in the following reaction: 2Cu2O + O2 → 4CuO?