Skip to main content
A

Anonymous

Oct 14, 2024

Catholics, how do you know whether a particular Catholic teaching is an infallible unchangeable doctrine or a fallible teaching?

Catholics, how do you determine whether a particular Catholic teaching is an infallible, unchangeable doctrine or a fallible teaching?

For example, limbo was consistently taught to the laity by saints like St. Augustine, and several popes issued statements about it since the Middle Ages. It even appeared in the Catechism until 1990. However, it was abolished in 2007, with the explanation that it was never an official doctrine.

In contrast, what about the Church's teaching on contraception? How can one ascertain whether the ban on contraception is an infallible teaching? How do we know it is a dogma? A thousand years from now, the Vatican might release a statement declaring it is no longer true. Where is it mentioned that certain teachings are unchangeable while others are changeable?

5 Answers

A
Anonymous

Dec 16, 2024

There are only two infallible (ex-Cathedra) teachings.

A) The bodily assumption of Mary into heaven

B) The immaculate conception

All the rest is doctrine.

J
Jada Kuhic

Feb 21, 2025

Compare it with bible teaching…. Those you have mentioned are not bible teaching, but teachings of man. Anything more than this can be summed up in 1 scriptures:

(Galatians 1:8, 9) . . .However, even if we or an angel out of heaven were to declare to you as good news something beyond the good news we declared to you, let him be accursed. As we have said before, I now say again, Whoever is declaring to you as good news something beyond what you accepted, let him be accursed.

A
Anonymous

Feb 22, 2025

Catholicism follows many anti Christian practices.

A
Anonymous

Jan 28, 2025

The Church will let you know. You’re not supposed to think about that kind of thing for yourself.

Just because individuals teach something doesn’t mean it’s doctrine. The Church never taught limbo. Augustine shacked up with a woman for decades and had at least one child. He then “saw the light” and blamed women for his sins.

Contraception stops the NATURAL act of conceiving/creating human life. Why wouldn’t an entity who believes that God is responsible for creating human life be against it? It is NOT doctrine however. You need to learn the difference. Most women who are Catholic that I know, including myself, have used the pill. Doctrine goes to the heart of why the religion exists. Neither limbo or contraception do that.

Want to answer this question?

Join our community to share your knowledge!

Related Questions

8
2) Juror 8 has raised ‘Reasonable Doubt about the boy’s guilt in this trial. Identify one element

Juror 8 has expressed "reasonable doubt" regarding the boy's guilt in this trial. Please identify one element that contr...

1
Aunt Louisa pays Thoreau’s taxes so that he can leave jail. Why is he upset that she has done this?

Aunt Louisa pays Thoreau's taxes to facilitate his release from jail. However, he feels upset about her actions. What ar...

8
Should 13 year olds show cleavage?

{"error":"400 The response was filtered due to the prompt triggering Azure OpenAI's content management policy. Please mo...

10
Is it true that some Catholic Priest and nuns wear chasitity belts ?

I have heard that some Catholic priests and nuns wear chastity belts. Some reportedly wear them permanently, while other...

1
What does hum num shavai mean in Jewish?

What does "hum num shavai" mean in Jewish? Could you please provide an explanation of this term, including any cultural...

5
What did john muir encourage president theodore roosevelt to do?

What specific actions did John Muir encourage President Theodore Roosevelt to take regarding environmental conservation...

9
Is it true that when it rains, God is crying?

I've heard that rain is often described as God's tears, and thunder is interpreted as Him throwing a tantrum when He is...

7
What does the word “Kyrie” mean in the following context?

I came across the phrase "Kyrie among nations" and looked it up in the dictionary, but the definition doesn't seem to fi...

10
What should I write in a gift bible?

I recently bought my six-year-old son his first real Bible, and I’d love to write something meaningful on the inside cov...

4
where can I find the words to the christian song “nothing is Impossible when you put your trust in God”

I recently heard the song "Nothing is Impossible When You Put Your Trust in God" during a Benny Hinn crusade, and I've b...