My daughter doesn’t want me in the delivery room when she has her baby?
My daughter, who is 24, is expecting her first child in January. This evening, she and her husband came over to visit, and we were discussing her birthing plan. During the conversation, she mentioned that she only wants her husband in the delivery room with her when she gives birth.
I didn’t share this with her, but her decision hurt my feelings. When I gave birth to my children, my mother was there with me, and it felt natural to have her support. All I want is to be there for my daughter and support her as she brings my granddaughter into the world.
I don’t want to pressure her or cause any tension, especially since there’s a possibility she might change her mind later. However, I can’t help but wonder why she wouldn’t want me there. I’m her mother, not a random stranger. Does anyone have any insight into this? Why might she feel this way?
10 Answers
My mom and MIL were in my room while I was being induced to keep me company, but when labor actually started I wanted as few people as possible. I just didn't want a private moment to be on display.
I really don't think you should make an issue out of this. She wants the event to be something between her and her husband, and that's FINE. Lots of laboring mothers feel that way. It's not personal, so don't make it about you. Instead, be ready to jump in and help with diaper changes, meal prep, laundry and housework, and watching the little one now and then while the new mama showers or naps. Be helpful and supportive without taking over. That's what a good grandma does.
Ultimately, it is her choice who is or isn't in the room. Honestly, I would NOT want my husband in the room because he'd probably complain that I was taking too long to push the baby out.
Things can be hectic & the more people you have in the delivery room, the more people will be talking and giving her a headache.
Your feelings are understandable, but it's still your daughter's choice.
It's probably because she and her husband would like that special bonding moment to be between them and their new baby. That's what we did with our first two and will do again with our next child. We allowed visitors before, all the way up until push time, then it was just us and the doctor/nurses. First, I would hold the baby skin to skin for several minutes, then daddy would have his turn. I'm sorry that she hurt your feelings. She certainly didn't intend to, but most likely wanted to prep you (as he probably did with his side of the family) for what to expect on that day. It's a personal choice, don't let it get you down. She's going to need you much more in the days after delivery.
Giving birth is not a spectator sport. It's very, very VERY hard work, and a time when women need a minimum of stress.
You do NOT have the right to be there, and your daughter doesn't need to give you a reason that she doesn't want you there. You don't need to see your grandchild being born, and if your daughter doesn't want you there, you will not be providing support -- you'll be increasing her stress.
Honestly, when I was pregnant, it never in a million years would have occurred to me to ask my parents to be present, and they never asked. The labor room contained the two people who were responsible for creating the baby, and the medical staff who were there to ensure that everything went safely. My mother wasn't there. My MIL wasn't there. My best friend wasn't there.
I agree with your daughter - she gets to choose who she wants with her, if she wants anybody with her.
I don't know what the big deal is -- women wanting everybody except their dog present when they give birth. Other than the medical personnel, I had no one with me and I can't say I missed them or needed them there.
For members of my generation, we had no choice in the matter: No family members (not even husbands) were ever allowed in the delivery room, under any circumstances. That was the accepted practice, and nobody complained about it.
My sister has been an obstetrical RN for years. She has always opposed family members (especially the mother of the woman giving birth) in the delivery room - that, for the most part, they just get in the way.
I don't know why she wouldn't want you in there. That sounds kind of rude of her to not want her own mother in there. I'm only 4 months, but I think I'd rather have my mom in the delivery room with me than my husband for some reason. My mom seems more comforting and she's been in my position before. I do want my husband in there as well, but would have to have my mom with me.
Jan 23, 2025
So you expect random strangers on the internet to be able to read your daughter's mind and tell you what she's thinking?
Yeah, you're certifiably lunatic. I wouldn't want you in the delivery room either.
Feb 02, 2025
You are two different people, she does not have to make the same choices you made and she may change her mind. I would step back and realize that her decisions are not about you but about her family and what she and her husband are the most comfortable with and that's their prerogative. It's not about you, it's about your daughter, her husband and their becoming a family.
We are expecting our first anytime now and that's what we've decided as well, just him and me. I don't want a bunch of people in there, its going to be a special moment for just the two of us to share and start our family with just the 3 of us. If I let my grandma that raised me mostly in if feel obligated to let my mom and fiancé's mom in there and that's just too many people and I'm not fond of his mom either. If I let one I'd hurt the rests feelings.
You should ask her why because she probably has a good reason that you didn't think of. I know that I wanted it just to be my husband and me when I gave birth and I didn't even text it to the family to 6 hours after it happened because birth was emotionally draining and I wanted it to be the three of us.
Categories
Tags
Related Questions
Aunt Louisa pays Thoreau's taxes to facilitate his release from jail. However, he feels upset about her actions. What ar...
I really dislike my teeth. When I lived with my dad, he never seemed to care much about me; he didn’t pay for me to go t...
I was watching the movie "Crimson Tide" and became curious about the ranks within a U.S. nuclear submarine. Specifically...
Why is the Ku Klux Klan retweeting Donald Trump, Jeff Sessions, and Steve King so frequently, yet somehow liberals are b...
Hi everyone, I’m trying to make a decision between enrolling my child in a preschool or a Montessori program. He’s curr...
What does it mean to sustain something, and what are the key principles or practices involved in achieving sustainabilit...
What factors contribute to the observed differences in SAT scores among African American students compared to their Whit...
I had my first child almost three weeks ago, born on September 15, 2022. She’s a healthy baby, and I’m just wondering if...
Is Miranda Cosgrove becoming less attractive as she gets older? It seems like they are using a lot of makeup to cover it...
I played Wizard101 on my other computer alongside some other games, and I had a lot of fun. However, my computer ended u...