Skip to main content
J

Jordan Auer

Jan 11, 2025

“Kindness is the beginning of cruelty.” Is this cruel statement true?

The quote, “Kindness is the beginning of cruelty,” attributed to Frank Herbert, raises a thought-provoking question about the nature of kindness and its potential consequences. Does this statement suggest that acts of kindness can lead to cruel outcomes? How should we interpret this paradoxical idea within the context of human behavior and ethics? I invite you to explore whether there is truth in Herbert's assertion and to consider examples from literature, history, or personal experiences that either support or challenge this claim.

5 Answers

A
Anonymous

Dec 03, 2024

When cruelty follows kindness it hurts more, is the point what Mr Frank Herbert has tried to bring home in his statement. The statement in fact is a kind of generalisation of what is merely one possible way a kindness can turn. It is common to understand that it is not cruelty that kindness is always a means of, kindness in its true form is not always for the purposed of being cruel latter, but most of time just to be good and decent to someone. In its true form kindness is an attribute of the good and strong. But then for the point the Mr Herbert is making, is strength not also needed to commit cruelty?

In any case, there is a link between kindness and cruelty, just as there is between love and hatred, the only difference being that when love turns into hatred, hatred cannot be turned back into love, but kindness and cruelty can go hand in hand, intertwined in the behaviour of the sickly and twisted for instance, causing greater hurtfulness and harm and by being just cruel or unkindly.

The second point is that sometimes one needs to be cruel to be kind – ‘I must be cruel to be kind’ Hamlet, Act 3, Scene 4, Lines 173-179. For what form a kindness should assume for the ones who do not understand the language of kindness, the message therein, the one who needs to be cured before being fed? Then the ends are in the purposes and not in the means. One might be kind only to cause more harm, as for instance when one’s kindness would encourage a bad behaviour, then one has no choice but to be resolute and firm. But question is not about resolution and firmness, but about the interesting situation they can arise out of the metal confusion that is caused when the mind suddenly turn cruel.

If you desire to perceive that every must have balance. Therefore, if you first have kindness (which we will consider the beginning) then eventually you must have cruelty (balance). As a result, kindness would be the beginning to cruelty.

A
Anonymous

Nov 02, 2024

It can sometimes

be so;

example; repeatedly forgiving someone`s

self-controllable unacceptable behaviour may well

result in its` becoming a close-to-uncontrollable trait.

I`m sure you can think of more examples.

A
Anonymous

Jan 24, 2025

No.kindness is the way to one’s heart.so how can it be way to cruelty

Want to answer this question?

Join our community to share your knowledge!

Related Questions

8
2) Juror 8 has raised ‘Reasonable Doubt about the boy’s guilt in this trial. Identify one element

Juror 8 has expressed "reasonable doubt" regarding the boy's guilt in this trial. Please identify one element that contr...

1
Aunt Louisa pays Thoreau’s taxes so that he can leave jail. Why is he upset that she has done this?

Aunt Louisa pays Thoreau's taxes to facilitate his release from jail. However, he feels upset about her actions. What ar...

8
Should 13 year olds show cleavage?

{"error":"400 The response was filtered due to the prompt triggering Azure OpenAI's content management policy. Please mo...

7
Me asap how does squeaky feel about taking care of raymond?

How does Squeaky feel about taking care of Raymond? Specifically, does she express any complaints or frustrations regard...

8
What is one way modernist writers use unreliable narrators to support their ideas about the world?

What is one way that modernist writers utilize unreliable narrators to convey their perspectives on the complexities of...

7
What are some adjectives that describe Edgar Allan Poe?

I am working on a project for my Extended School Year program, and I need some adjectives to describe Edgar Allan Poe fo...

9
Is it true that when it rains, God is crying?

I've heard that rain is often described as God's tears, and thunder is interpreted as Him throwing a tantrum when He is...

1
Me n my bff were eating chinese n what does this fortune mean?

My best friend and I were eating Chinese food, and I got a fortune that says, “Adversity is the parent of virtue.” Can s...

10
What is opposite of coincidence?

What is the opposite of coincidence, and how can it be defined in different contexts?

9
Where can I find the lyrics to that Brazilian song, “Hey, Magdalena”?

I've heard this Brazilian song several times, and I'm trying to find its lyrics. It's in 4/4 time and has a constant dru...